OTTAWA—Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney doubled down on his pointed World Economic Forum speech, directly contradicting U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent’s assertion that he had softened his stance during a private call with President Donald Trump. “To be absolutely clear, and I said this to the president, I meant what I said in Davos,” Carney told reporters on Parliament Hill Tuesday, emphasizing Canada’s resolve amid escalating trade tensions.
The dispute traces back to Carney’s Jan. 20 address in Davos, Switzerland, where he declared the U.S.-led global order in the “midst of a rupture.” He warned that the “bargain” of American hegemony “no longer works,” as “great powers” weaponize tools like tariffs. The remarks, delivered amid Trump’s aggressive push for Europe to sell Denmark-owned Greenland, drew a rare standing ovation from world leaders and executives. Carney framed the speech as Canada recognizing shifts in U.S. trade policy and responding accordingly, according to CNBC.
Trump fired back the next day, asserting “Canada lives because of the United States. Remember that, Mark, next time you make your statements,” as reported by multiple outlets including BBC News. By Friday, he rescinded Canada’s invitation to his newly formed “Board of Peace,” a group initially for Gaza reconstruction but eyed as a UN rival, via a Truth Social post: “Please let this Letter serve to represent that the Board of Peace is withdrawing its invitation to you regarding Canada’s joining,” per The New York Times.
Davos Remarks Ignite Firestorm
Carney’s Davos speech urged “middle powers must act together because if you are not at the table, you are on the menu,” without naming Trump but amid his Greenland pressure and tariff threats. The address praised Canada’s pivot, including a Jan. 16 preliminary deal with China lowering tariffs on select goods like 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles at 6.1% duty in exchange for eased barriers on Canadian canola and seafood, as detailed by National Post.
Over the weekend, Trump escalated on Truth Social, threatening “100% Tariff against all Canadian goods and products coming into the U.S.A.” if Ottawa pursues a China deal, dubbing Carney “Governor Carney” in a nod to his 51st-state quip. Bessent echoed on ABC’s “This Week”: “We can’t let Canada become an opening that the Chinese pour their cheap goods into the U.S.,” tying it to upcoming USMCA renegotiation, according to PBS News.
Carney countered Sunday: Canada has “no intention” of a free trade deal with China, respecting USMCA obligations, while clarifying the sectoral pact resolves prior tariffs without breaching the trilateral agreement, as covered by CNBC.
Phone Call Clash Emerges
Monday’s Trump-Carney call covered Ukraine, Venezuela, Arctic security (Greenland shorthand), and Canada’s partnerships. Carney boasted of “12 new deals on four continents in six months—he was impressed.” But Bessent, claiming to be in the Oval Office, told Fox News’ Hannity: “He spoke to Prime Minister Carney, who was very aggressively walking back some of the unfortunate remarks he made at Davos.” Bessent added, “Canada depends on the U.S…. The prime minister should do what’s best for the Canadian people rather than try to push his globalist agenda,” per Reuters.
Carney dismissed this Tuesday: “No,” when asked if he walked back remarks, calling the talk “very good” and reiterating Canada’s diversification while openness to USMCA renewal. He noted nearly nothing is “normal” in U.S. policy, with review imminent, as in Reuters.
Reactions poured in: TIME reported Carney’s approval surging post-Davos while Trump’s dipped, framing him as middle-power leader against U.S. coercion (TIME). On X, users debated, with posts like “Someone is lying” linking Global News coverage.
Trade Deal Sparks Alarm
The China pact, capping EVs at 3% of Canada’s market initially and drawing Chinese auto investments, alarmed Washington fearing a backdoor for cheap goods into North America. Bessent warned of “disaster for Canada” via tariffs, criticizing Carney’s “virtue-signal to his globalist friends at Davos” on ABC, echoed in The New York Times.
Canada’s U.S. trade minister Dominic LeBlanc likened it to Trump’s own China deals, insisting no free trade pursuit. Carney positioned diversification—70% of exports U.S.-bound—as response to tariffs, building “principled and pragmatic” ties abroad, per The Globe and Mail.
X chatter highlighted divides, with Canadian users backing Carney’s pushback against perceived U.S. bullying.
Broader Fault Lines Exposed
Beyond tariffs, Arctic security nods to Trump’s Greenland bid strained NATO ties. Carney’s speech, analyzed by Carnegie Endowment as signaling hedging against “unpredictable and predatory” U.S., resonated globally, per Wikipedia summary of coverage.
Trump’s Board of Peace snub—joined by nations like Saudi Arabia but shunned by liberal democracies—underscores fractures. Carney distanced early, citing details like $1 billion fee, as in ABC News.
USMCA review looms, with Bessent hinting Canada-China moves factor in. Carney eyes positive reset, but tensions signal volatile North American trade ahead.
Global Echoes and Domestic Boost
Carney’s defiance boosted polls, positioning Canada as middle-power bulwark. World leaders praised; Trump allies decried “ingratitude.” X posts amplified: “Carney already publicly refuted… Trump doesn’t like being upstaged.”
As tariffs threaten integrated supply chains—goods crossing borders multiple times—stakeholders watch. Carney vows resilience: building home, abroad, and via USMCA.